Skip to main content
In this exhibit:

Robert R. Livingston: Writing Without a Vote

Robert R. Livingston helped draft the Declaration even though New York’s delegates were not yet allowed to vote for independence. His experience shows how the colonies moved toward unity at different paces.

Writing Without Authority

Robert R. Livingston played an important but often overlooked role in the drafting of the Declaration of Independence. As a member of the Committee of Five, he helped shape the document that announced independence to the world. Yet Livingston faced a unique challenge.

As a delegate from New York, he was not authorized to vote for independence when Congress debated the issue.

In 1776, delegates were expected to follow instructions from the governments that sent them. While other colonies authorized support for independence, New York had not yet done so. As a result, New York's delegates could debate independence and even help write the Declaration, but they could not vote for it until new instructions arrived.

Images
Half length portrait of a white man. He wears a black coat.
Image Credit Line

Collection of the New York Historical Society, Gift of Goodhue Livingston Jr. View in the NYHS Collections.

People

Robert R. Livingston

New York Delegates to the New York Provincial Congress, 8 June 1776, in Smith, Letters of Delegates, 4:171–72.

“Your Delegates here expect that the question of independance will very shortly be agitated in Congress. Some of us consider ourselves as bound by our instructions not to vote on that question & all wish to have your sentiments thereon.”

New York Delegates to the New York Provincial Congress, 8 June 1776.

Primary Source

New York Delegates to the New York Provincial Congress, 8 June 1776

Read the transcription of New York Delegates to the New York Provincial Congress, June 8, 1776, in Smith, Letters of Delegates, 4:171–72.

While others pushed forward, Livingston had to wait for instructions from home. His experience highlights the tension between writing independence and formally approving it.

Limits from New York

Livingston was deeply involved in the Committee of Five’s work. He reviewed drafts at least twice, discussed language, and helped prepare the Declaration for presentation to Congress. At the same time, New York’s provincial authorities put limits on his authority. Unlike Virginia or Massachusetts, New York had not yet approved voting for independence. As a result, Livingston could help write the Declaration but could not vote for it.

This position was frustrating and confusing. Livingston believed independence was necessary and inevitable. He wrote back to leaders in New York, urging them to act quickly so their delegates could join the decision. His letters show that the delay was due to political timing and uncertainty at home. New York was still reorganizing its government and facing military threats.

But Livingston was not hesitant.

New York Provincial Congress to the New York Delegates, 11 June 1776, Papers of the Continental Congress, Item 67, 1:228–31.

“They are unanimously of Opinion that You are not authorized by your Instructions to give the Sense of this Colony on the Question of declaring it to be and continue an Independent State.— Nor does this Congress incline to instruct You on that Point, it being a matter of Doubt, whether their Constituents intend to vest them with a Power to deliberate & determine on that Question. Indeed the Majority of this Congress are clearly of Opinion that they have no such Authority.”

New York Provincial Congress to the New York Delegates, 11 June 1776.

Images
Handwritten document from NY Provincial Congress to the NY Delegates, 11 June 1776, page 1.
Handwritten document from NY Provincial Congress to the NY Delegates, 11 June 1776, page 2.
Handwritten document from NY Provincial Congress to the NY Delegates, 11 June 1776, page 3.
Primary Source

New York Provincial Congress to the New York Delegates, 11 June 1776

Read the transcription of New York Provincial Congress to the New York Delegates, June 11, 1776, PCC, Item 67, 1:228–31

New York’s provincial leaders explained to their congressional delegates in June 1776 that they did not yet have the authority to vote for independence. This instruction meant that Livingston, as well as the other delegates, could help discuss independence but could not yet vote for it.

Unity in Progress

Livingston’s situation reminds us that independence did not move at the same pace in every colony. The Declaration was drafted in a moment when unity was still forming. Writing the document was easier than achieving full agreement across thirteen colonies.

New York Delegates to the New York Provincial Congress, 17 June 1776, in Smith, Letters of Delegates, 4:258–59.

“We recd. great pleasure from knowing the sentiments of the hon. the Convention, relative to the important subject on which we thought it our duty to ask their opinion. We are very happy in having it in our power to assure them, that we have hitherto taken no steps inconsistant with their intention as expressed in their letter, by which we shall be careful to regulate our future conduct.”

New York Delegates to the New York Provincial Congress, 17 June 1776.

Primary Source

New York Delegates to the New York Provincial Congress, 17 June 1776

Read the transcription of New York Delegates to the New York Provincial Congress, June 17, 1776, in Smith, Letters of Delegates, 4:258–59.

The New York delegation replied that they would follow their leaders’ instructions carefully.

A Decision Still Unfolding

As the vote approached, the New York delegates warned their leaders that independence might be declared before they received new instructions.

New York Delegates to the New York Provincial Congress, 2 July 1776, in Smith, Letters of Delegates, 4:371–72.

“The important Question of Indepency was agitated yesterday in a Committee of the whole Congress, and this Day will finally be determined in the House. We know the Line of our Conduct on this Occasion; we have you Instructions, and will faithfully pursue them. New Doubts and Difficulties however will arise should Independency be declared … every Colony (ours only excepted) having withdrawn their former Instructions, and either positively instructed their Delegates to vote for Independency; or concur in such Vote if they shall judge it expedient;. What Part are we to act after this Event takes Place; every Act we join in may then be considered as in some Measure acceding to the Vote of Independency, and binding our Colony on that Score.”

New York Delegates to the New York Provincial Congress, 2 July 1776.

Primary Source

New York Delegates to the New York Provincial Congress, 2 July 1776

Read the transcription of New York Delegates to the New York Provincial Congress, July 2, 1776, in Smith, Letters of Delegates, 4:371–72.

The delegates understood that independence was likely, but they still felt bound by New York’s earlier instructions.

This is why early versions emphasized Congress acting on behalf of the colonies, rather than claiming full unanimity. Only later, after New York granted permission, could the Declaration be described as unanimous.

Rough draught of the declaration of independence, cropped to show the title of the document

“A Declaration by the Representatives of the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA in General Congress assembled”

Jefferson's draft identified the document simply as a declaration made by the representatives in Congress. At this point, Congress had approved independence but it was not unanimous. Not every colony had authorized its delegates to support it.

Engrossed Declaration of Independence, cropped to show the document's title

“The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen colonies of the united States of America”

Once New York authorized independence on 9 July, printers and officials could describe the Declaration as “The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen united States of America.” This revised language showed that all 13 states stood behind the decision.

Support without a Signature

Livingston’s role shows how carefully that unity was constructed. Independence was not a single moment, but a process that unfolded over weeks. Because New York’s delegates could not vote, the Declaration adopted on 4 July did not include their approval. On 9 July 1776, the New York Provincial Congress approved the Declaration. This eventual support made the Declaration unanimous and perhaps created a false narrative that every colony agreed fully from the start. 

Although Livingston supported the Declaration, other New York delegates did not. John Alsop, a merchant, was among that group. On 16 July, after the New York Provincial Congress reported that New York was “a free and independent State,” he resigned. Reconciliation, Alsop believed, was still possible. 

John Alsop to the New York Provincial Congress, 16 July 1776, in Smith, Letters of Delegates, 4:466–67.

“I am compelled, therefore, to declare that it is against my judgment and inclination. As long as a door was left open for a reconciliation with Great Britain, upon honourable and just terms, I was willing and ready to render my country all the service in my power, and for which purpose I was appointed and sent to this Congress; but as you have, I presume, by that declaration closed the door of reconciliation, I must beg leave to resign my  seat as a Delegate from New-York.”

John Alsop to the New York Provincial Congress, 16 July 1776.

Primary Source

John Alsop to the New York Provincial Congress, 16 July 1776

Read the transcription of John Alsop to the New York Provincial Congress, 16 July 1776, in Smith, Letters of Delegates, 4:466–67.

Explaining his decision, Alsop wrote that independence went against his judgment. Alsop’s resignation shows that even in July 1776, some American leaders still hoped for reconciliation with Britain.

Images
Black and white print illustrating two buildings. In the top half, a one-story building, identified as the County Clerks and Surrogates Office; in the bottom half a two story building with a cupola, identified as the Ulster County Courthouse.
Primary Source

Courthouse Wall St. City of Kingston, N.Y., in F.W. Beers' County Atlas of Ulster New York (1875)

Robert R. Livingston supported the drafting of more than one revolutionary document. Following his role on the Committee of Five, he return to New York where he contributed to the development of  New York's first state constitution. The New York Provincial Congress adopted that constitution on 20 April 1777, less than a year after the publication of the Declaration of Independence. They ordered that it be posted to the door of the courthouse of Kingston, NY, where they had been meeting. Though that courthouse was later burned by the British, another courthouse (as pictured above, in a print from 1875) was erected on the same site.

Livingston’s name is missing from the list of signers on the final parchment. This absence has sometimes been misunderstood as reluctance. This is inaccurate. Livingston left Congress in July to help lead and design New York’s new state government. By the time the engrossed copy was signed in August, he was no longer present.

His absence reminds us that signing the Declaration was not the same as supporting it. Many who shaped independence did so through drafting, debate, and state-level leadership rather than signatures alone.