Skip to main content
In this exhibit:

Roger Sherman: Law, Balance, and Authority

Roger Sherman helped ensure the Declaration worked as a clear, practical document. His legal judgment and support moved the draft forward.

A Legal Mind at Work

Roger Sherman is one of the least remembered members of the Committee of Five, but his role was important. Unlike Jefferson or Franklin, Sherman was not known for grand writing or diplomacy. He was a lawyer and legislator who focused on structure, clarity, and law.

Sherman, from Connecticut, had been a critic of British governance since the 1760s. He helped ensure that the Declaration worked as a legal document, not just a political statement. He believed independence had to rest on careful reasoning and agreement. His presence on the committee reflected the need for balance. He reviewed the document at least twice.

Images
Full length portrait of a white man. He is sitting and wearing a brown suit.
Image Credit Line

Yale University Art Gallery.

People

Roger Sherman

Reviewing and Moving Forward

Sherman brought a practical legal mindset to the drafting of the Declaration. He had long experience in colonial government and understood how laws were debated, revised, and accepted. While Jefferson drafted the text and Franklin refined its tone, Sherman reviewed and approved the work.

John Adams to Timothy Pickering, 6 August 1822.

“We reported it to the Committee of Five. It was read and I do not remember that Franklin or Sherman criticized any thing. We were all in haste; Congress was impatient and the Instrument was reported, as I believe in Jefferson’s hand writing as he first drew it.”

John Adams to Timothy Pickering, 6 August 1822.

Images
Cursive handwriting. Page 1 of Adams to Pickering 6 August 1822.
Cursive handwriting. Pages 2 and 3 of Adams to Pickering 6 August 1822.
Cursive handwriting, with John Adams' signature. Page 4 of Adams to Pickering 6 August 1822.
Primary Source

John Adams to Timothy Pickering, 6 August 1822

Read the transcription of John Adams to Timothy Pickering, August 6, 1822

According to John Adams, Sherman did not raise objections when the draft came before the committee. Congress and the committee were in a hurry, and the document moved forward quickly.

Although Sherman left fewer visible marks on the page, Adams’s account helps us understand his role. Sherman’s silence was not indifference. It reflected confidence in the draft and a desire to move the work ahead. His example reminds us that history is shaped not only by dramatic edits, but also by steady judgment and trust within a team.

Thomas Jefferson to Roger Sherman Baldwin, 9 March 1822.

“I served with him in the Old Congress in the years 1775. & 1776. he was a very able and logical debater in that body, steady in the principles of the revolution, always at the post of duty, much employed in the business of Committees, and particularly was of the Committee of Dr Franklin, mr J. Adams, mr Livingston & myself for preparing the Declaration of Independance. being much my senior in years, our intercourse was chiefly in the line of our duties. I had a very great respect for him, and now learn with pleasure that the public are likely to be put into possession of the particulars of his useful life.”

Thomas Jefferson to Roger Sherman Baldwin, 9 March 1822.

Primary Source

Thomas Jefferson to Roger Sherman Baldwin, 9 March 1822

Read the transcription of Thomas Jefferson to Roger Sherman Baldwin, March 9, 1822.

Jefferson valued Sherman’s experience and long appreciated his support.

A Trusted Voice

Sherman’s role also shows that the men on the Committee of Five had many other duties. Sherman was the only member of Congress to serve on the committees that drafted the Declaration of Independence, the Articles of Confederation, and later the Constitution. During the Revolutionary Era, he earned a reputation for having sound judgment. He woke up early, began work in the morning, and labored until late at night.

Sherman worked on issues that ranged far beyond the Declaration. He helped manage supply purchasing for the army, handled Native American affairs, and took part in running the post office. He served on the Board of War in 1776 and later on the Board of Treasury. Though he was not known for graceful speeches, he was respected for his sound judgment. Even friends who joked about his stiff manner agreed that he was one of the most sensible and reliable men in Congress.

Annotated Timeline of Committee Appointments

Working Beyond the Declaration

The Declaration of Independence was only one of many urgent responsibilities before Congress in the summer of 1776. This infographic follows the Committee of Five's committee appointments alongside the drafting of the Declaration, revealing how its members managed war, diplomacy, finance, communications, and the creation of a new government.

John Adams to Robert Waln Jr., 19 November 1822.

“The Honble: Roger Sherman was one of the most cordial friends which I ever had in my life. Destitute of all literary and scientifick education but such as he acquired by his own exertions, he was one of the most sensible men in the World. The clearest head and the steadiest heart.”

John Adams to Robert Waln Jr., 19 November 1822.

Images
Two cursive handwritten letters from a microfilm scan.
Primary Source

John Adams to Robert Waln Jr., 19 November 1822

Read the transcription of John Adams to Robert Waln Jr., November 19, 1822.

John Adams remembered Sherman years later as one of the most reliable and thoughtful leaders of the Revolutionary era.

This reputation, which helps explain why people trusted Sherman so fully, shaped how the Connecticut delegate approached the Declaration. He favored language that could bring the colonies together. He supported revisions that stressed shared action and common purpose. His choices made the document less dramatic but more durable. Sherman’s work helped turn bold ideas into a statement strong enough to last. His example reminds us that revolution required powerful words and a clear understanding of the potential consequences.

Roger Sherman and America's Founding Documents

Roger Sherman is the only person to sign all four of America's principal founding documents. His signature appears at every major constitutional milestone, from resistance to British rule to the creation of the United States.

Read the transcription of Continental Association, 20 October 1774.
Print of the Declaration of Independence. Roger Sherman's signature is highlighted.
Read the transcription of The Declaration of Independence.

John Adams to Robert Waln Jr., 19 November 1822.

“Mr Sherman was born in the State of Massachusetts and in the Town of Dedham, and was one of the soundest and strongest pillars of the Revolution.”

John Adams to Robert Waln Jr., 19 November 1822.

Images
Two cursive handwritten letters from a microfilm scan.
Primary Source

John Adams to Robert Waln Jr., 19 November 1822

Read the transcription of John Adams to Robert Waln Jr., 19 November 1822.